Brunel
Home EuroView
Home Deliverables
Implementing An Organizational Directory
Service
11. Cost Analysis
This section presents a breakdown of the costs you can expect within
the project life cycle, together with a look at the savings that should
come about when the service is up and running. As with all IT projects
a reliable cost benefit analysis is difficult to perform so be wary that
any figures given here, though based on experience with several user sites,
are estimates only and are derived using several assumptions.
Actual costs and manpower required will vary considerably depending on
circumstances. As such any figures provided in this section should be used
for rough guidance only. The main use of this section is as a `shopping
list' of cost items which can be used as the basis for a more appropriate
estimate of projected expenditure.
11.1 Outlay
11.1.1 The Development Phase
The length and cost of the development phase will vary considerably.
Larger organisations will require greater planning effort as a result of
more complex and distributed management models. Specific factors:
-
Multiple and varied data sources. Organizations may have distributed
data sources. All e-mail addresses, for example, may not be managed at
a single point, especially if the organisation is geographically distributed.
Similarly different data sources may need to be employed for different
kinds of information, e.g. the e-mail database for e-mail addresses, the
internal phone book (if available electronically) for phone numbers, etc.
-
Multiple sites. An organisation with many sites will require a more
involved service design, especially in the areas of replication and security.
-
Complex data model. A complex management model will correspond with
a complex data model, especially if a functionality rich directory service
is required.
-
External staff affiliation. Larger enterprises are likely to make
use of non-permanent staff or have on-site workers belonging to closely
co-operating external organisations. This means that a significant number
of workers will contribute to the data management overhead - short term,
contract or seconded staff may not be stored in the personnel database
and will then require loading from other sources. The greater movement
of such staff will also add to the total amount of change required in the
directory database.
-
Politics. Co-operation is required between various management elements
of the enterprise. The bigger an organization the greater the need for
`buy in' by and the subsequent backing of upper management.
Importantly the need for use of external expertise in the form of consultants
will add heavily to the cost of service development. In most cases some
outside help will be required. Here the discussion is based on the assumption
that the service will not be outsourced but developed in-house with a certain
amount of consultation taking place. Purchased bespoke solutions will of
course carry their own price tags.
Development Activity |
Medium Organizations
(500-1000 staff) |
Large Organizations
(1000-5000 staff) |
Assess base position
Locate data sources.
Assess data maintenance requirement.
Examine network infrastructure.
|
1 man month |
2 man months |
Specification
User survey.
Specific requirements.
|